Jamaican Kamina Johnson Smith sprints to depose Baroness Patricia Scotland, says she’s no British puppet

Johnson Smith said she saw the common purpose, unity and shared English-language links of the Commonwealth as central to making the organization a more proactive global force, tackling issues such as climate change.

Johnson Smith denied that her challenge for the top job was too late to be effective.

“As one foreign minister said to me, if she had to put her money on anyone in a sprint it would be on a Jamaican woman. So I have taken that, I’ve owned it,” she laughed.

The Jamaican’s nomination follows the aborted attempt by Kenya’s Monica Juma to challenge Scotland for the job. Scotland has alienated many countries in the bloc including the UK and Australia.

Johnson Smith and Juma were both accused, by supporters of Scotland, of being British puppets.

The minister said she was offended by that suggestion.

“Not only national offense but personal offense,” she said. “The role we’ve played in decolonization, liberation, in human rights and in the promotion of democracy globally, should speak for itself, that we’ve long acted as a nation beyond our size.”

Johnson Smith’s candidacy has split the Caribbean bloc, the largest within the group, and threatens to upset African nations.


This is because under convention, a secretary-general’s term runs four years and re-election is typically unchallenged, meaning the term usually runs for eight years.

Because Scotland’s term was extended by two years due to the pandemic and the twice-delayed CHOGM meeting, she has said she would seek just two more years, after which it would be Africa’s turn to field a candidate.

Johnson Smith confirmed she was seeking a four-year term and that a second term would be up to Commonwealth members.

She rejected criticism of her nomination as divisive, saying she was running to unify the organization that became split under Scotland.

“Democracy is all about choice and presenting more than one choice, particularly where it has been encouraged, there were countries across many regions that encouraged me to come forward,” she said.


“The UK is supportive of my candidacy … they’re not the only country,” she said adding India, Singapore, Maldives, Grenada and Belize also backed her..

Under the Morrison government, Australia was thought to be strongly campaigning for Johnson Smith, but this is believed to have shifted to a more neutral stance since the change of government in May.

Scotland was plagued by early funding rows about how she managed the bloc’s finances, leading to Australia, the UK and New Zealand pulling funding.

Johnson Smith said proper governance of the Commonwealth, so that more funding could be spent on improving living standards across the family of nations, was her core commitment.

Get a note directly from our foreign correspondents on what’s making headlines around the world. Sign up for the weekly What in the World newsletter here.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.